ALE vs RIE: what is the difference?
Reactive ion etching has been the main way to transfer patterns into thin films for decades. As transistors became three-dimensional and critical layers shrank to a few nanometres, some steps needed control that a continuous, time-based etch struggles to give. Atomic layer etching, the removal counterpart of atomic layer deposition, was developed for those steps. In practice the two are complementary, and many advanced etch chambers can run both modes.
The short answer
ALE (atomic layer etching) removes material in repeated cycles of two self-limiting steps, surface modification and removal, so each cycle takes off a fixed amount close to one atomic layer regardless of small process variations. RIE (reactive ion etching) etches continuously with plasma ions and radicals, so depth depends on rate and time. ALE offers finer depth control, better selectivity and lower damage; RIE is far faster and remains the workhorse for most pattern-transfer steps.
Side-by-side comparison
| Aspect | ALE | RIE |
|---|---|---|
| Removal mode | Cyclic: modify the surface, purge, remove the modified layer, purge | Continuous: radicals and ions act at the same time |
| Depth control | Set by the number of cycles; each removes a fixed amount, typically sub-nanometre | Set by etch rate multiplied by time, with endpoint detection |
| Uniformity | Self-limiting steps make results insensitive to local flux variations | Depends on uniformity of plasma, gas flow and temperature |
| Selectivity | High when the removal step energy sits below the threshold for the underlying material | Depends on chemistry and ion energy; harder to keep at very small thicknesses |
| Ion energy and damage | Low-energy ions (plasma ALE) or no ions (thermal ALE); minimal damage | Higher ion energies can damage or roughen layers below |
| Throughput | Low, because many cycles are needed for meaningful depth | High |
| Directionality | Plasma ALE is directional; thermal ALE is isotropic | Anisotropic, tuned through ion energy and sidewall passivation |
| Typical uses | Final, critical nanometres of an etch; thin channel and spacer layers; surface smoothing | Trenches, contact holes, vias, gate stacks and most pattern transfer |
How an ALE cycle works
A typical plasma ALE cycle for silicon starts by exposing the surface to chlorine, which bonds only to the top atomic layer. After the excess gas is purged, low-energy argon ions bombard the surface with enough energy to remove the chlorinated layer but not enough to sputter the unmodified silicon below. A second purge removes the products, and the cycle repeats.
Because both steps stop by themselves, the amount removed per cycle depends on surface chemistry rather than on exposure time. That is the source of ALE's depth control, its insensitivity to small variations across the wafer, and its ability to stop on an underlying material that does not respond to the same modification step.
Why RIE remains the workhorse
RIE combines chemically active radicals with ions accelerated toward the wafer, and both act simultaneously. Etch rates are high, profile control through gas chemistry, pressure and bias is well understood, and the equipment base is mature. Most of a pattern-transfer etch, from opening a hard mask to cutting a deep contact hole, does not need atomic precision and benefits from RIE's speed.
The limitations show at the end of an etch, when only a few nanometres remain above a thin layer that must not be damaged, and in features where etch rate varies with aspect ratio. Many processes therefore use RIE for the bulk of the depth and switch to ALE-like cyclic steps for the final part, or alternate deposition and etch steps in a quasi-atomic-layer mode.
Plasma ALE and thermal ALE
Plasma ALE uses directional ions in the removal step and therefore etches mainly downward, which suits anisotropic pattern transfer. Thermal ALE uses only gas-phase reactions, such as fluorination followed by ligand exchange, and removes material equally in all directions. That makes it suitable for uniform lateral trimming inside three-dimensional structures, at the cost of slower cycles and chemistries specific to each material.
Where ALE is used in advanced devices
ALE is applied where a few atomic layers decide device performance: controlled recessing of thin films, etching of gates and spacers in FinFET and gate-all-around transistors, and smoothing of etched surfaces. Gate-all-around transistors also need highly selective isotropic removal of silicon-germanium layers between silicon nanosheets; this is done with selective isotropic etches, among which atomic-layer and other cyclic approaches are one option rather than the only method.
FAQ
Will ALE replace RIE?
Unlikely. ALE is slow and is used where its precision is needed. Most etch steps tolerate the variations of continuous etching and benefit from RIE's throughput, so fabs combine the two, often within the same chamber.
How much does one ALE cycle remove?
Usually less than a nanometre, often a fraction of a single atomic layer to about one layer, depending on the material and chemistry. The value is called the etch per cycle and is roughly constant over a range of process conditions, which defines the ALE window.
Is ALE the same as atomic layer deposition in reverse?
Conceptually yes: both use sequential, self-limiting surface reactions separated by purges. The chemistries differ, and plasma ALE adds an ion-energy window in which the modified layer is removed but the unmodified material is not.
Is ALE damage-free?
Thermal ALE uses no ions, so ion-induced damage is avoided. Plasma ALE uses ions with energies close to the sputtering threshold of the modified layer, so damage is much lower than in conventional RIE but not necessarily zero.
Terms compared
- Atomic Layer Etching (ALE)An etching technique that removes material roughly one atomic layer per cycle using two self-limiting steps, giving very precise depth control.
- RIE (Reactive Ion Etching)The main form of dry etching, in which reactive radicals and ions from a plasma act together to remove material vertically and transfer patterns with straight side walls.
- Etch SelectivityThe ratio between the etch rate of the film being removed and that of the mask or underlying layer that must remain.
Japanese companies involved
- Tokyo Electron (TEL) · Coat/develop, etch and deposition equipment
- Hitachi High-Tech · CD-SEM metrology, defect inspection and etch systems
- SAMCO · Plasma etching, CVD and plasma cleaning equipment
- Daikin Industries · Etching gases, fluoropolymers and fluoroelastomers
- Kanto Denka Kogyo · Fluorine-based specialty gases
More etching comparisons
Sources
Semiconductor comparisons
- All semiconductor comparisons
- Ion implantation vs thermal diffusion: what is the difference?
- Front-end vs back-end process: what is the difference?
- FinFET vs GAA: what is the difference?
- NAND vs DRAM: what is the difference?
- HBM vs GDDR6: what is the difference?
- HBM3E vs HBM4: what is the difference?
- SiC vs GaN: what is the difference?
Last updated: November 2, 2026