SiC MOSFET vs IGBT: what is the difference?
The IGBT (insulated-gate bipolar transistor) has been the standard high-voltage switch in motor drives, inverters, railway traction and electric vehicles since the late 1980s. SiC MOSFETs have taken over a growing share of EV traction inverters, on-board chargers and solar inverters, especially in 800 V systems. The choice now turns on efficiency, switching frequency and cost.
The short answer
A SiC MOSFET is a unipolar transistor made of silicon carbide; an IGBT is a bipolar-assisted silicon transistor. Because the SiC MOSFET conducts with electrons only, it has no tail current at turn-off, so switching losses are much lower and it can run at tens to hundreds of kilohertz, and its resistive on-state lowers loss at light load. The silicon IGBT has a fixed on-state voltage drop and higher switching loss, but it is cheaper, robust and well proven at high current and voltage.
Side-by-side comparison
| Aspect | SiC MOSFET | Silicon IGBT |
|---|---|---|
| Material and carriers | Silicon carbide; unipolar (electrons only) | Silicon; bipolar conduction (electrons and holes) |
| On-state behaviour | Resistive (RDS(on)); loss falls sharply at partial load | Fixed knee voltage plus slope (VCE(sat)); loss does not fall as much at light load |
| Turn-off | No tail current; very low switching loss | Tail current while stored carriers recombine |
| Typical switching frequency | Tens to hundreds of kHz | A few kHz to about 20 kHz in power converters |
| Reverse conduction | Built-in body diode, or synchronous conduction through the channel | Needs a separate anti-parallel diode |
| Common voltage classes | 650 V, 1200 V, 1700 V; 3.3 kV in some modules | 600 V to 6.5 kV |
| Maximum junction temperature | Typically 175 °C in commercial parts | Typically 150 to 175 °C |
| Gate drive | Higher and often asymmetric gate voltages; fast edges need careful layout | Mature, tolerant gate drive |
| Cost | Higher, driven by SiC wafer and process cost | Lower, on mature silicon processes |
| Typical uses | EV traction inverters, on-board chargers, DC-DC converters, solar inverters, fast chargers | Industrial drives, railway traction, UPS, welding, many EV and hybrid inverters |
Why the SiC MOSFET switches with less loss
An IGBT is a MOSFET combined with a bipolar transistor. When it is on, holes are injected into the drift region and lower its resistance, which keeps conduction loss low even at high voltage. At turn-off those stored carriers must recombine before the current stops, so a tail current flows while the voltage is already high. That tail is the main reason IGBT switching losses are high and switching frequencies are kept low.
Silicon carbide's breakdown field is about ten times that of silicon, so a SiC device can hold 1200 V with a thin, low-resistance drift layer without carrier injection. The SiC MOSFET therefore stays unipolar, turns off without a tail and can switch much faster. Higher frequency allows smaller inductors, capacitors and filters, and lower loss allows smaller heat sinks.
Conduction loss and partial load
An IGBT's on-state voltage has a knee of roughly a volt before current rises, so even small currents produce noticeable loss. A MOSFET behaves like a resistor, so loss falls with the square of the current. Since EV traction inverters spend most of their time at partial load, this matters: SiC inverters reduce losses most in typical driving rather than at peak power, which extends range for a given battery or allows a smaller one.
At very high current an IGBT's voltage drop can match or beat a SiC MOSFET of the same chip area, and IGBT modules have long field records in railway and industrial drives. SiC MOSFETs also bring new design issues: faster voltage edges increase electromagnetic interference and stress motor insulation, and the gate oxide needs careful reliability qualification.
Which to use when
SiC MOSFETs fit where efficiency, power density and high switching frequency justify a higher device price: 800 V EV traction inverters, on-board chargers, fast DC chargers, solar and storage inverters, and server power supplies above the GaN voltage range. IGBTs remain the economical choice for cost-sensitive EVs and hybrids, industrial drives, welding, UPS and very high-power converters where switching frequency is low anyway. Some inverters combine both, using SiC and IGBT chips in parallel.
Japan is strong in both technologies. Mitsubishi Electric, Fuji Electric, Toshiba and Hitachi Power Semiconductor Device are long-standing IGBT module makers, and ROHM, Mitsubishi Electric, Toshiba, Fuji Electric and Denso produce SiC MOSFETs and modules.
FAQ
Is there a silicon carbide IGBT?
SiC IGBTs have been demonstrated for ultra-high voltages, around 10 kV and above, where even SiC MOSFETs would need very thick drift layers. They are research and niche devices; commercial SiC power transistors are almost all MOSFETs.
Why are SiC MOSFETs more expensive than IGBTs?
SiC wafers are grown slowly by sublimation and are costly and small, defect control is harder, and processing needs high-temperature ion implantation and activation anneals above 1,600 °C. Silicon IGBTs are made on cheaper, larger wafers with mature processes.
Do all electric vehicles use SiC inverters?
No. SiC is common in 800 V platforms and in vehicles where efficiency and range justify the cost, while many vehicles, particularly lower-cost models and hybrids, still use silicon IGBT inverters.
Terms compared
- SiC MOSFET (Silicon Carbide MOSFET)A power MOSFET built in silicon carbide instead of silicon, switching high voltages fast and efficiently; widely used in EV inverters and chargers.
- IGBT (Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor)A voltage-driven power switch that combines a MOSFET gate with bipolar conduction, used in inverters for motors, trains, EVs and renewable energy.
- Silicon Carbide (SiC)A wide-bandgap compound of silicon and carbon whose high breakdown field and thermal conductivity make it the leading material for high-voltage power devices.
- Power SemiconductorSemiconductor devices built to switch, convert and rectify electric power at high voltage and current, such as power MOSFETs, IGBTs and diodes.
Japanese companies involved
- ROHM · SiC and silicon power devices, analog ICs
- Mitsubishi Electric (power devices) · IGBT and SiC power modules, RF and optical devices
- Denso · Automotive power semiconductors, sensors and ICs
- Toshiba Electronic Devices & Storage · Power MOSFETs, IGBTs and discrete semiconductors
- Fuji Electric (power semiconductors) · IGBT modules and SiC power devices
- Resonac · CMP slurries, packaging materials and SiC epitaxial wafers
- Sumitomo Electric Industries (compound semiconductors) · SiC epitaxial wafers and GaAs and InP substrates
- Tokyo Electron (TEL) · Coat/develop, etch and deposition equipment
More power semiconductors comparisons
Sources
Semiconductor comparisons
- All semiconductor comparisons
- CoWoS vs SoIC: what is the difference?
- CoWoS vs InFO: what is the difference?
- Chiplet vs monolithic: what is the difference?
- Hybrid bonding vs flip chip: what is the difference?
- TSV vs wire bond: what is the difference?
- Wafer test vs final test: what is the difference?
- HTOL vs burn-in: what is the difference?
Last updated: November 2, 2026