Single patterning vs multi-patterning: what is the difference?
Every lithography scanner has a minimum pitch it can print in one exposure, set by its wavelength and numerical aperture. When ArF immersion reached that limit around 80 nm pitch and EUV was not yet ready, chipmakers kept shrinking interconnects and fins by adding process steps instead. Multi-patterning made the 20 nm-class and later logic and memory nodes possible with DUV, and it is still used today, both with DUV and, at the very tightest pitches, with EUV.
The short answer
Single patterning defines a layer with one lithography exposure, so its finest pitch is set by the scanner's resolution. Multi-patterning goes beyond that limit either by splitting the pattern across several litho-etch passes (LELE) or by using deposited sidewall spacers to double or quadruple the line density from one exposure (SADP, SAQP). It shrinks pitch by a factor of two to four, at the cost of many more process steps, extra cut masks and tighter control of overlay and line widths.
Side-by-side comparison
| Aspect | Single patterning | Multi-patterning |
|---|---|---|
| Lithography exposures for the main pattern | One | Two or more for LELE; one mandrel exposure plus cut or block exposures for SADP and SAQP |
| Minimum pitch | Limited to the scanner's single-exposure resolution | About 1/2 (double patterning) to 1/4 (quadruple patterning) of the single-exposure pitch |
| Main error sources | Dose, focus and resist effects within one exposure | Overlay between exposures (LELE); spacer and mandrel width variation, called pitch walk (SADP, SAQP) |
| Process steps | Coat, expose, develop, etch | Repeated deposition, etch, clean and metrology steps plus additional masks |
| Design freedom | Layouts limited only by the scanner and design rules | Layouts must be split into colours (LELE) or restricted to regular, mostly one-directional gratings (SADP, SAQP) |
| Typical methods | DUV or EUV single exposure | LELE, LELELE, SADP, SAQP, SALELE |
| Cost and cycle time | Lower per layer | Higher: more tool passes, more masks and longer cycle time |
| Typical use today | Most layers, and EUV-printed critical layers | Fins and tight metal layers with ArF immersion; the tightest EUV layers at advanced nodes |
How the main multi-patterning methods work
LELE (litho-etch-litho-etch) splits a dense layout into two sparser patterns, often described as two colours. Each is exposed and etched in turn, and the two interleave to form the final layer. LELE keeps design flexibility, but any misalignment between the two exposures directly changes the spacing between neighbouring features, so overlay must be extremely tight. Triple patterning (LELELE) extends the idea at the price of a third mask.
SADP (self-aligned double patterning) prints only a sparse mandrel pattern. A conformal film, usually deposited by ALD, coats the mandrels; an etch leaves this film only on their sidewalls, and the mandrels are then removed. Each mandrel leaves two spacers, doubling the line density, and because the spacing is set by the film thickness rather than by a second exposure, overlay between lines is not an issue. SAQP repeats the spacer step to quadruple the density. Unwanted line segments are then removed with separate cut or block exposures.
The trade-offs of multi-patterning
Each extra pass through deposition, etch, clean and metrology adds cost, cycle time and opportunities for defects. Self-aligned methods also introduce pitch walk: if mandrel or spacer widths drift, alternate spaces become unequal. Cut and block masks still need precise overlay, and edge placement error, the combined effect of overlay and line-width variation, becomes the limiting metric.
Design is constrained too. Layouts for SADP and SAQP are built on regular gratings with lines in one direction, and electronic design automation tools must check that any layout can be decomposed into manufacturable patterns.
How EUV changed the picture
EUV at 13.5 nm can print in one exposure pitches that ArF immersion could only reach with SADP or SAQP, so its introduction removed many multi-patterning sequences from critical layers. That simplification, not resolution alone, is a large part of EUV's economic case.
Multi-patterning has not disappeared. Chipmakers still weigh EUV single exposure against cheaper DUV multi-patterning on layers where both work, and the very tightest metal pitches in the most advanced nodes may use EUV double patterning. High-NA EUV aims to bring some of those layers back to single exposure.
FAQ
When is SADP preferred over LELE?
SADP suits dense, regular line-and-space patterns such as fins and tight metal layers, because the line spacing is set by a deposited film rather than by aligning two exposures. LELE is more flexible for irregular shapes, such as contacts and vias, but depends on very tight overlay between the two exposures.
How small a pitch can DUV multi-patterning reach?
With ArF immersion, whose practical single-exposure limit is around 80 nm pitch, SAQP can produce pitches in the low 20 nm range. In practice the limit is set less by physics than by cost, yield and the accumulation of overlay and line-width errors across many steps.
What is SALELE?
SALELE, self-aligned litho-etch-litho-etch, combines two litho-etch passes with self-aligned features such as spacers, so that some edges are defined by deposited films rather than by overlay. It has been proposed for tight metal layers at 5 nm and below, including with EUV.
Does multi-patterning need different tools from single patterning?
It uses the same kinds of tools, but many more of them per layer: scanners and coater-developers for each exposure, deposition tools for conformal spacers, etch and clean tools for each transfer, and more overlay and line-width metrology to control the accumulated errors.
Terms compared
- EUV (Extreme Ultraviolet)Light with a 13.5 nm wavelength used to print the finest chip patterns; it needs mirrors, vacuum and a tin-plasma light source.
- Multi-PatterningForming patterns finer than one exposure can resolve by repeating lithography, deposition and etch steps; it carried ArF immersion lithography down to the 10 and 7 nm nodes.
- Immersion Lithography (ArFi)ArF lithography with ultrapure water between the lens and wafer, raising the numerical aperture above 1 to print finer patterns.
Japanese companies involved
- HOYA · Mask blanks (including EUV) and photomasks
- AGC · EUV mask blanks and glass materials
- Mitsui Chemicals · EUV pellicles and wafer protection tapes
- JSR · Photoresists and semiconductor materials
- Tokyo Ohka Kogyo (TOK) · Photoresists and high-purity process chemicals
- Rapidus · Leading-edge logic foundry (2 nm, in development)
- Lasertec · EUV mask and mask blank inspection
- Nikon · ArF, KrF and i-line lithography systems
More lithography comparisons
Sources
Semiconductor comparisons
- All semiconductor comparisons
- Chemically amplified resist vs metal oxide resist: what is the difference?
- ALD vs CVD: what is the difference?
- CVD vs PVD: what is the difference?
- PECVD vs LPCVD: what is the difference?
- MOCVD vs MBE: what is the difference?
- Dry etching vs wet etching: what is the difference?
- ICP vs CCP: what is the difference?
Last updated: November 2, 2026